Traders present petition against Tesco Metro in Ashtead Village

Streatham Guardian: Tyron Patterson and Roger Palmer are two of the traders in The Street who are against Tesco's proposal Tyron Patterson and Roger Palmer are two of the traders in The Street who are against Tesco's proposal

Civil war has broken out between traders over Tesco’s controversial plans to build a new Metro store in Ashtead.

A petition against the plans has been submitted to Mole Valley Council signed by 45 businesses, including 24 businesses in The Street where the new Tesco Metro would be located.

It was handed over to planners on June 14 by Roger Palmer, owner of Palmers Deli Cafe; Tyron Patterson, manager of Greenwise Greengrocers; both in The Street, and John Bates, owner of Ashtead Fisheries in Rectory Lane.

The petition, which calls for a smaller store with on-site parking, said it was written to "balance the views" expressed by Bryan Elphick, chairman of the Ashtead Village Traders Association (AVTA) - who it said has given the impression that most traders in Ashtead Village support the application.

But Mr Elphick, who said a majority of AVTA members support a new Tesco, said he had spoken out "to balance the views of the SAVE campaigning group which is adamantly against the Tesco in its present form".

Mr Palmer said some AVTA members did not feel their views were being represented and that AVTA also only represents about 50 per cent of businesses in The Street.

The petition stated: "There are businesses who signed this petition who are members of the AVTA so even within the AVTA there are those who do not want this store.

"The impact of Tesco on both Lower Ashtead and the village traders should not be ignored in the belief that Tesco provides a quick fix to a number of traders who support the scheme."

The petition has also attracted signatures from businesses in other retail areas it said will be "significantly affected" including Craddocks Avenue and Barnett Wood Lane - with 11 and 10 businesses having signed from each.

Acknowledging that AVTA does not represent all the traders in the village, Mr Elphick said: "The majority of AVTA members, who are traders in The Street, are in favour of the store being developed as soon as possible because of the level of economic activity in the village.

"It needs the extra footfall."

He said he was "quite surprised" that as many as 24 businesses in The Street had signed the petition but there were still a "fair few signatures from those not in The Street, who are not the people I represent".

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

10:41pm Wed 27 Jun 12

EpsomGal says...

This has been going on for so long the people of ashtead don't want a food shop of any type so...let them starve!!
This has been going on for so long the people of ashtead don't want a food shop of any type so...let them starve!! EpsomGal

11:50pm Thu 28 Jun 12

ticktock says...

Well when the council puts all the shops rates up there won't be any shops left in epsom
Well when the council puts all the shops rates up there won't be any shops left in epsom ticktock

9:05am Mon 2 Jul 12

Joy Wemms says...

There is no civil war and candidly by using such emotive language the Guardian is belittling its own position as a valued local Newspaper.

Another leading Newspaper undetook an independent survey of the Traders actually in The Street. This reported the majority of the traders in favour of getting building underway and a having a store that will attract footfall into The Street as soon as possible.

The Ashtead Traders Association represents ALL the businesses in The Street, not in Craddocks or Barnet Lane.

Craddocks and Barnet Lane have enjoyed good patronage from the local community in recent years, deservedly so, they have a good range of small artisan shops backed by a thriving supermarket, that happens to be Tesco's.

The Street has been the silent victim of a prolonged, assertive campaign to restrict Tesco's developing its land. A number of small stores and one bank have already become casualties, suffering from both the recession and the lack of foot fall in the Street.

In recent months, things have become calmer and the commnity spirit of The Street is once more raising its head. Many have worked hard to encourage this and see the new found team spirit vital to the future of the Street

Lets have no more of these emotive and inaccurate head lines... they only serve to damage The Street further... after all who wants to shop in an area that is defined as a civil war zone.
There is no civil war and candidly by using such emotive language the Guardian is belittling its own position as a valued local Newspaper. Another leading Newspaper undetook an independent survey of the Traders actually in The Street. This reported the majority of the traders in favour of getting building underway and a having a store that will attract footfall into The Street as soon as possible. The Ashtead Traders Association represents ALL the businesses in The Street, not in Craddocks or Barnet Lane. Craddocks and Barnet Lane have enjoyed good patronage from the local community in recent years, deservedly so, they have a good range of small artisan shops backed by a thriving supermarket, that happens to be Tesco's. The Street has been the silent victim of a prolonged, assertive campaign to restrict Tesco's developing its land. A number of small stores and one bank have already become casualties, suffering from both the recession and the lack of foot fall in the Street. In recent months, things have become calmer and the commnity spirit of The Street is once more raising its head. Many have worked hard to encourage this and see the new found team spirit vital to the future of the Street Lets have no more of these emotive and inaccurate head lines... they only serve to damage The Street further... after all who wants to shop in an area that is defined as a civil war zone. Joy Wemms

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree